Journal
Learning to Win the Long Way
Oct 18, 2026

St. John's beat Rutgers 104-99 in four overtimes Sunday afternoon at Madison Square Garden, in front of 11,041 people. It was an exhibition, so it doesn't count in the record or in anybody's season totals. You wouldn't have known it from the way they played.
The first half wasn't pretty. The Johnnies made just two of their last 15 shots and went into the locker room down 46-28. Rutgers scored on the first trip of the second half to make it 48-28. Then St. John's ran off 16 straight points, six different guys scored on the run, and just like that it was a ballgame again.
Rutgers went back ahead 71-69 with 38 seconds left, and Quinn Ellis tied it on a layup with 23 seconds to go. After that it was 76-76, then 89-89, then 94-94. By the third overtime it felt like a Mets game in extra innings, when you stop looking at your watch and just settle in. Finally, in the fourth overtime, St. John's ran off six straight, didn't miss at the line down the stretch, and won the period 10-5.
Keyshawn Hall had 24 points and 14 rebounds and went 10 for 10 from the free throw line, which is the kind of thing that matters when you play 52 minutes. Ian Jackson also scored 24. Tounde Yessoufou had 15 points and three steals, and Babacar Sane gave them 13 in only 15 minutes. Ellis had 13 points, nine assists, eight rebounds and four blocks, and in 56 minutes with the ball in his hands most of the day, he turned it over once. Once. That's a point guard you can trust in a close game.
Rutgers deserves credit. Tariq Francis scored 24, Christian Gurdak had 20 points and 15 rebounds, and they outrebounded St. John's 58-51. The Johnnies also went 6 for 30 from three. Those are October problems. What stood out more is that St. John's won the paint 58-40 and held Rutgers to 4 of 21 from three. That's Pitino defense, and it showed up when it needed to.
Here's the thing I keep coming back to. Even in an exhibition, it's good to learn how to win. This is a new group, and coming back from 20 down and then winning a fourth overtime is something they can lean on in February. Pitino got four extra periods to see who wants the ball when it's tight, and he'll learn a lot about this team from it and keep building.
Next up is Texas, the last exhibition, Sunday, Oct. 25 at noon at the Garden.